Skip to Content

20 Collectible Board Games In Your Attic That Can Sell For Hundreds

A board game from 1860 taught players about virtue and honesty, and surviving copies have sold for thousands of dollars. Its designer used a spinning top instead of dice, which still makes me grin whenever I mention it.
Condition and completeness drive most prices, so a worn box with missing pieces usually brings far less money. Sealed boxes and early editions can bring much more, but prices change from month to month.
I love the rattle of old dice and the musty smell that drifts out of a long-closed lid. Most copies sell for modest sums, so treat every number here as a possibility instead of a promise.
Twenty vintage board game finds are waiting below, and a few of them could be hiding in your attic. Which dusty box on your own shelf do you think holds the biggest surprise of them all?

1. 1935 Monopoly White Box Number 9

1935 Monopoly White Box Number 9
© eBay

Open an old Monopoly box and look for a small bank compartment tucked inside the tray. Parker Brothers sold the 1935 white box edition, and collectors still hunt for it.

Early boards also show blue printing on the GO square and lack prices on the properties. Complete copies in good shape have sold for roughly $330 up to about $1,500 depending on condition.

Hi! This post may contain affiliate links to online stores. If you use a link and buy something, I may get a commission at no extra cost to you. See my affiliate disclosure.

Missing pieces and cracked boxes cut the price quickly, so check every token and every card carefully. Store it flat in a cool, dry closet, since attic heat can warp boards and fade the lids.

2. 3M Jati

3M Jati
© Mandi’s Attic Toys

Estimates say only 100 to 1,000 copies of Jati were made, mostly for reviewers and testing. 3M released it in 1965 as part of its Bookshelf Games line, packaged to look like a book.

You place tiles and try to outthink your opponent, so two players is the natural fit. Reported sales have landed between about $560 and $1,000, with one eBay sale noted near $725 recently.

Look for the slim book-style box with the 3M logo, and make sure every tile is present. Because so few exist, a verified complete set deserves careful photos before you list it anywhere.

3. Fireball Island 1986

Fireball Island 1986
© Reddit

The sculpted plastic mountain with its giant glaring idol steals the whole table, even before anyone rolls. Milton Bradley launched Fireball Island in 1986, and players race to grab a jewel while marbles tumble down.

Complete original sets in good shape often sell for roughly $75 to $200 on resale sites. Mint copies in the box can pass $400, and single replacement parts sometimes bring $10 to $30.

Modern reissues exist, so check the box for the 1986 date and original artwork before paying. Count the trees and bridges first, because missing plastic pieces hurt the value more than a dented lid.

4. Disney Haunted Mansion Game Of Life

Disney Haunted Mansion Game Of Life
© eBay

A ghostly twist on the family classic puts a famous theme park ride right on your kitchen table. Collectors who love Disney and tabletop history both chase this themed edition, so competition among buyers can get lively.

Recent reported sales have hovered around $250 per copy, though prices swing with condition and completeness. Check the box for the Disney licensing marks, because several other Game of Life editions look similar.

The spinner keeps rules simple, so a family night with this edition works well for most ages. Keep the tiny plastic cars and pegs in a zip bag, since lost pieces lower what buyers will pay.

5. Dark Tower 1981

Dark Tower 1981
© Reddit

A black plastic tower that lights up and makes sounds felt like pure magic when I first saw one. Milton Bradley released Dark Tower in 1981, and one to four players journey through a fantasy kingdom.

Production reportedly ended early after a legal dispute, so complete working units are quite scarce today. Functioning sets have sold for roughly $200 to $500, and a few exceptional copies passed $650.

Test the electronics with fresh batteries, since a tower that stays silent is worth much less. Keep the original cards and playing pieces with the tower base, and remove old batteries before storing it.

6. Star Wars Queen’s Gambit

Star Wars Queen's Gambit
© slothgamerefresher

Avalon Hill built a sprawling Star Wars strategy game in 2000 with modular boards and 155 plastic miniatures. It follows scenes from Episode I, including a palace with three levels, and the table fills up fast.

Players manage action cards and move forces across several boards at once, so the game rewards patient planning. Clear a big table first, because the multiple boards and plastic miniatures take up a surprising amount of space.

Complete copies in good condition have sold for around $555, though that is one reported figure. Count all 155 miniatures and every card before buying, because missing figures are hard to replace.

7. Milton Bradley Hotels

Milton Bradley Hotels
© Etsy

Building lavish resorts on a colorful board gave many kids a thrill that simple trading games rarely matched. Milton Bradley published Hotels in the late 1980s, and players buy land, then add towers and entrances.

Listings date it to either 1987 or 1988, so check the box carefully before describing your copy. A complete 1988 copy sold for about $206, and a sealed 1987 edition reportedly reached $300.

Plenty of used copies sell for much less, so condition and sealed status make the biggest difference. Check that the plastic hotel pieces are all there, since matching replacements are tough to find online.

8. Milton Bradley Séance 1972

Milton Bradley Séance 1972
© Antique Trader

Milton Bradley invited players to chat with a ghost in 1972, and the idea still gives me goosebumps. The ghost reveals secrets as the game unfolds, which made Séance stand out on crowded toy shelves.

Complete copies in good condition usually sell for roughly $100 to $200 on major resale sites. Exceptional examples have topped $300, but those are the best cases and not the typical result.

Inspect the box corners and the board for water stains, which are common in attic storage. Take clear photos of every piece, because buyers of spooky games love to see the details.

9. Voice Of The Mummy 1971

Voice Of The Mummy 1971
© Reddit

A record player that speaks for a mummy was a clever surprise at the kitchen table in 1971. Milton Bradley used the record to deliver mysterious messages as players explore the mummy’s tomb for treasure.

Finding a complete copy with a working record is the hard part, and that drives the price. Copies often sell for $100 to $200, and a few in excellent condition have passed $300.

Check the record for scratches, since a skipping disc takes away much of the fun for buyers. Store the record upright in its sleeve, away from heat, so it does not warp over time.

10. The Legend Of Zelda Board Game 1988

The Legend Of Zelda Board Game 1988
© Zelda Universe

Link’s first big adventure jumped from the television screen onto the kitchen table in 1988. Milton Bradley asked players to gather Triforce pieces and rescue Princess Zelda while facing monsters along the way.

Nintendo fans and board game fans both want it, so sold copies often land between $100 and $300. One sealed and graded copy reportedly sold for $2,880, which is a rare exception and not a normal sale price.

Look for the original board and cards with the plastic pieces, since a partial set sells for far less. Sun fades box art quickly, so keep it shelved away from windows and in a dry room.

11. 3M Acquire World Map Edition

3M Acquire World Map Edition
© Acquisition Games

Sid Sackson designed this hotel chain game, and 3M published early editions in the 1960s in slim bookshelf boxes. Players build and merge hotel chains, then earn money by owning stock in the biggest ones.

Collectors prize the World Map edition, and sold prices have ranged from about $150 to $500. Later 3M printings are more common and usually bring only $20 to $50, so edition matters.

Compare your stock certificates with online photos, because early versions had different certificate counts per chain. Acquire plays best with three to six players, so confirm the tiles and play money are all present.

12. James Bond 007 Underwater Battle

James Bond 007 Underwater Battle
© MillionsofToys

A Thunderball tie-in game appeared in the mid-1960s. Players guide frogmen and a mini submarine through an underwater scene inspired by the movie’s climax.

Small pieces were easily lost, so complete sets with a good box are rare to find today. Used copies have sold near $350, while pristine and complete sets have reached between $1,600 and $1,800.

Check every plastic figure and the submarine, because broken or missing parts cut the price sharply. Fans of spy films will enjoy the box art, so photograph it well and keep it flat.

13. The Elvis Presley Game 1957

The Elvis Presley Game 1957
© conducimos

The Elvis Presley Game from 1957 wears a pink and black box with his photo and a party-ready tagline. Players spin and answer trivia about love, etiquette, or Elvis himself, which makes it a quirky time capsule.

Limited production makes complete, well-kept copies hard to find, and prices reflect that scarcity in a big way. Damaged copies have sold around $650, while good ones have reached roughly $2,000 to $3,000 on auction sites.

One recent eBay sale landed near $663, so reported prices vary widely depending on condition and completeness. Check the spinner and cards, and compare your box with trusted photos to help avoid modern reproductions.

14. Remco Lost In Space 3D Action Fun Game 1966

Remco Lost In Space 3D Action Fun Game 1966
© CVTreasures

Cardboard space travel got wild in 1966 when Remco turned a television show into a multi-level game. Players try to reach Earth before running out of fuel while crossing an alien planet with many small pieces.

Those small parts get lost easily, so complete copies are tough to find in any decent condition. A good complete copy has sold for around $340, which shows how much fans value the show.

A Greek version published by Remoundo reportedly sold for $800, so international editions can bring extra interest. Check any foreign language on the box, since that detail might separate a common copy from a rare one.

15. HeroQuest 1989

HeroQuest 1989
© Reddit

One player became the evil sorcerer and the others played heroes, and my friends argued over that role constantly. Milton Bradley released HeroQuest in 1989, and its detailed miniatures turned a dining table into a dungeon.

Complete original sets often sell for $100 to $300, depending on the box and the miniatures. UK buyers report £80 to £100 for played copies and sealed ones near £450 to £500.

One copy reportedly sold for $899.99 in May 2021, which is an exception worth knowing about. Check that the plastic furniture and the monster figures are present, and keep the quest book safe.

16. Mystery Date 1965

Mystery Date 1965
© Mandi’s Attic Toys

Opening that big white door and wondering who stood behind it was half the fun in 1965. Milton Bradley made it a fashion matching game, so players collect outfit cards that fit one of four dates.

Complete copies in good condition usually sell for about $75 to $200 on major resale sites. Recent eBay sales of the 1965 version have landed between roughly $125 and $129, which fits that range.

Check that the door still swings freely and that all of the date and outfit cards survive. Later versions look different, so compare the box art to a 1965 photo before listing your copy.

17. Original Mouse Trap 1963

Original Mouse Trap 1963
© Etsy

Cranking the handle and watching a marble roll through the contraption was my favorite part of Mouse Trap. Ideal released the original in 1963, and its Rube Goldberg style trap gets built piece by piece.

Complete 1963 sets in good condition typically sell for about $50 to $150 on resale sites. Incomplete or worn copies bring less, and the best prices go to fully intact, well-kept boxes.

Count the plastic parts carefully, since a missing gear or bucket can stop the whole machine. Many later editions exist, so look for the 1963 date and Ideal name on the box.

18. The Checkered Game Of Life 1860

The Checkered Game Of Life 1860
© Google Arts & Culture

Instead of buying houses, players in 1860 chased virtues like Truth and tried to avoid Idleness. Milton Bradley published The Checkered Game of Life that year, using a teetotum instead of dice for each turn.

Players aimed for Happy Old Age, so the board worked like a lesson in good habits. Verified complete examples have sold at auction for roughly $1,500 to more than $4,000, though such finds are rare.

An 1866 version has also appeared at auction, so later printings can be valuable too. Contact an auction house or museum if you find one, and handle the paper with clean, dry hands.

19. Cootie 1949 First Edition

Cootie 1949 First Edition
© eBay

A plastic bug built from colorful body parts reached toy shelves in 1949 from Schaper Manufacturing Company. Players roll dice and collect parts, and the first person to finish the whole bug wins.

Early boxes show a drawn cartoon bug on the lid, while later boxes switched to photographs. First edition plastic feels heavier and less shiny, and excellent complete sets have sold for $150 to $300.

Later Cootie sets are common and sell for much less, so the early details matter a lot. Wash plastic parts gently with mild soap and let them dry before storing them in the original box.

20. Swift Meats Major League Baseball F162 1957

Swift Meats Major League Baseball F162 1957
© REA

Punch-out baseball player figures make this odd little 1957 promotional game a fascinating find. The set could include stars like Brooks Robinson, Willie Mays, Roberto Clemente, and Mickey Mantle, according to listings.

A complete set has been valued around $1,800 to $2,644, though full set sales are infrequent. Individual cards have sold for hundreds of dollars, and the board alone has reached up to $900.

Handle any cards with clean hands and slip them into protective sleeves before you do anything else. A grading company or auction house can authenticate them, which helps buyers trust what they are buying.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

     

    Join the My Kind of Meeple newsletter!

    Exclusive email updates! New Strategies, Kickstarter Picks, What I'm Playing + Special Extras!

    Thanks for joining!

    Your email is only used for updates and email-based ad targetting. (Ads keep this site free!) You can view the terms & can opt-out of email-based ad targetting here.

    Featured in

    CBR
    Legit
    Sfu
    Brightside